Some 84% of indies view supermarkets as a threat to their business

Tesco still has to roll out its ‘new look’ card department.
Tesco still has to roll out its ‘new look’ card department.

Supermarkets are viewed as the biggest competitive threat to an independent greeting card retailer’s business, beating Card Factory, Paperchase and print-on-demand operators hands down as retailers they fear the most.

Supermarkets topped the poll in the Progressive Greetings/Cardgains Retail Barometer annual research survey into the health and wealth of the independent greeting card retailer when asked what retailers they see as the biggest threat to their business, due to their enviable footfall, invariably free parking as well as improvements in their greeting card selection and display.

Sainsbury’s is scoring well with its improved card selection.
Sainsbury’s is scoring well with its improved card selection.

Card Factory is still up there on the threat front, but it is almost as though indies have become more confident in the co-existence with the UK’s largest card retailer. “It is interesting how almost half of the indies respondents now feel neutral about Card Factory – and 4% seeing them as a boon to business, seemingly confident that their selection and customer service differentiates their independent store with the value giant,” commented Warren Lomax, joint owner of Progressive Greetings, which runs the annual research programme with buying group Cardgains.

According to the survey, Moonpig, Funky Pigeon, Thortful  (and other print-on-demand operators) are now viewed as more of a threat to an indie’s business than multiples retailers Paperchase and Clintons.

 

How do you view the supermarkets’ expansion on the greeting card front?

21% Serious Threat

63% Threat

13% Neutral

3% Bonus

(Source: PG/Cardgains Retail Barometer).
(Source: PG/Cardgains Retail Barometer).

 

How do you currently view Card Factory?

17% Serious Threat

37% Threat

42% Neutral

4% Bonus

(Source: PG/Cardgains Retail Barometer).
(Source: PG/Cardgains Retail Barometer).

 

How do you currently view Clintons?

4% Serious Threat

9% Threat

82% Neutral

5% Bonus

 

How do you view Moonpig, Funky Pigeon and other print-on-demand operators?

4% Serious Threat

31% Threat

65% Neutral

0% Bonus

The quick service and enormous number of permutations make print-on-demand operators, such as Moonpig a threat to an indie’s business.
The quick service and enormous number of permutations make print-on-demand operators, such as Moonpig a threat to an indie’s business.

 

How do you currently view Paperchase?

5% Serious Threat

5% Threat

90% Neutral

0% Bonus

 

*Fuller results from the PG/Cardgains Barometer will be revealed in the February edition of Progressive Greetings.

MORE NEWS
story 3 - feature pic-5
 
Publisher ‘espresso-ed’ its environmental stand at PG Live with new range ...
Story 4 feature pic-53
 
Retailers make the most of the final sales push for the fourth Spring Seasons event ...
story 2 feature pic-52
 
The opening of BGC’s ninth branch form part of the wholesaler’s ambitious expansion plan ...
Story 5 feature pic-55
 
Fiona Trees, owner of Memorable Moments, Ripon, reveals her stores’ hot sellers. ...
Story 1 feature pic-57
 
A trio of leading retailers share the products that stood for them at the recent PG Live ...
Story 1 - feature pic-2
 
Relive the fun of the fair as the PG Live photo gallery goes live ...
Get the latest news sent to your inbox
Subscribe to our daily newsletter